Pros and Cons of Different Types of Rodent Traps

Rodents are prevalent across the United States, and South Florida is no exception. Many rodents – house mice, deer mice, Norway rats, etc. – are common in Florida, especially if you live in coastal cities like Coral Springs. Although rodents are small, they cause significant harm to your property and cause health risks to humans. Several approaches or traps exist to tackle rodent infestations; however, there are certain pros and cons of rodent traps.

This article will discuss a common method for rodent control and prevention—rodent traps—along with their pros and cons. So, let’s dive in!

Snap Traps

Snap traps are a commonly used method for effective rodent control and removal. They consist of a spring-loaded metal bar or wire triggered when a rodent enters the trap and disturbs a pressure-sensitive trigger mechanism. Once triggered, the metal bar snaps shut with force, trapping the rodent inside or delivering a lethal blow to kill it instantly.

Snap traps come in various sizes and accommodate different rodent species. Moreover, they are made of materials like wood or metal that are durable and easy to clean. Here are the pros and cons of rodent traps (Snap Traps):


  • Effectiveness: Snap traps are known for their high success rate in capturing or killing rodents quickly.
  • Affordability: They are relatively inexpensive and widely available, making them a cost-effective option for rodent control.
  • Reusability: These traps can be reused multiple times, making them a sustainable and practical choice.


  • Regular monitoring and resetting: You need to monitor and reset the snap traps to maintain their effectiveness, which can be time-consuming.
  • Potential harm to non-target animals: There is a risk of inadvertently trapping non-target animals, such as pets or beneficial wildlife.

Live-Capture Traps

Live-capture traps, also known as humane traps, catch rodents without causing harm or killing them. These traps have a box-like shape with one or more entry points. The rodents are lured inside, and once they are in, the trap springs and capture them. Live-capture traps are often used for relocating rodents to a different location away from human habitation. Let’s discuss a few pros and cons of rodent traps (Live-Capture Traps):


  • Very humane approach: With a live-capture trap, you can humanely get rid of rodent infestations by capturing them without causing harm or death.
  • Chemical-free: In contrast to chemical-based traps, live-capture traps do not involve toxic substances, making them safer for humans, pets, and the environment.
  • Easy to set up: Live-capture traps are easy to set up, as they require simple assembly and bait placement. This makes them accessible for homeowners and individuals who don’t have specialized knowledge or training in rodent control or roof rat removal.


  • Ineffective for large infestations: Live-capture traps can capture 15 to 30 mice, but they aren’t effective for addressing large-scale rodent infestations
  • Time-consuming: Capturing rodents alive can be time-consuming, as you need to monitor traps regularly to check for captured rodents.

Electric Traps

Electric traps are a modern and innovative method of rodent control. These traps use an electric current to kill the rodent quickly. Typically, these traps are made of a chamber with metal plates or grids that deliver an electric shock. When the rodent enters the trap for the lure you’ve placed in it, it gets electrocuted and dies immediately. Electric traps aren’t completely humane, but they are better than snap traps. Following are the pros and cons of rodent traps (Electric traps):


  • Humane and swift: Compared to other traditional rodent or mouse control methods, electric traps provide a humane method of eliminating rodents as they quickly and efficiently kill them.
  • Easy set up: Electronic mouse traps or electric traps are easy to set up, requiring simple bait placement and activation. This makes them user-friendly and accessible for effective rodent control.
  • Safe: The electrical current in electric traps is contained within the trap and poses minimal risks to humans and pets.


  • Regular cleaning and maintenance: Electric traps may require regular maintenance – cleaning and checking for any issues to ensure proper functioning.
  • High initial cost: Electric traps are more expensive than traditional snap traps or rodent control methods.
  • Indoor use only: These traps are used indoors as they require a power source and may not be suitable for outdoor environments. This restricts their effectiveness in addressing outdoor rodent problems.

Bait Stations or Poison Traps

Bait stations are plastic boxes with entry points holding rodenticide baits, while poison traps combine a trapping mechanism with poison bait. These methods aim to attract rodents to consume the toxic bait, leading to their elimination. You should remember to be cautious and follow all preventive measures to protect your loved ones, pets, and other animals. Here are the pros and cons of rodent traps (Bait Stations and Poison Traps):


  • High effectiveness: Bait stations and poison traps can effectively eliminate rodent populations, especially when properly placed and used according to manufacturer instructions.
  • Wide coverage: These methods can target multiple rodents simultaneously, making them suitable for addressing larger infestations.


  • Risky for other animals or pets: The use of toxic baits carries risks, as they can be harmful to humans, pets, and non-target wildlife if not handled and secured correctly.
  • Secondary poisoning: Rodents that consume the poison bait may be eaten by predators, leading to potential secondary poisoning of those animals.

Glue Traps

A glue trap uses a sticky adhesive surface to trap and catch rodents and is made of a flat board coated with a rodent-trap adhesive material. The rodent comes in contact with the adhesive and gets stuck. These traps can be placed on your walls or in areas where rodent activity is observed to capture rodents as they walk over the trap’s surface. Let’s discuss the pros and cons of rodent traps (Glue Traps):


  • Simple usage: Glue traps are simple to set up and require no additional bait or chemicals.
  • Extensive application: They can be used indoors and outdoors to catch a variety of small rodents and insects.


  • Messy and unhygienic: Removing trapped rodents from glue traps can be messy and unpleasant, requiring careful handling to avoid contact with the trapped animal.
  • May cause harm to non-target animals: Glue traps can also catch non-target animals, such as birds or reptiles, resulting in unintended damage.


There are many pros and cons of rodent traps, so you should choose those traps that suit your needs. Before finalizing any rodent trap, you should also consider other factors, like whether you’ve pets at home or want to use the traps outdoors. When in doubt, it’s always best to call in the professionals. Gregory’s Pest Control also helps you with rodent removal or mice control.

At Gregory’s, we have sustainable rodent traps that eliminate the root cause of rodent infestation and keep your family and pets safe. We utilize advanced traps and techniques to make your home free from all rodent infestations and protect your health and property. So get in touch with us today to get immediate services!

Paul Gregory employee photo

Paul Gregory

Owner/President of Gregory’s Pest Control

I’m a 2nd generation pest control owner who started working for my father in 1999. I was raised in South Florida and feel blessed to call it home for my entire adult life. As a long-term Florida resident, I recognize the challenges of controlling the many different pests that thrive in our subtropical climate. In particular, I understand how difficult it can be to prevent pests from invading our homes and businesses. By helping families solve their pest problems so they can live safer, more comfortable lives, I feel I am also meeting my family’s commitment to help our community. When I’m not out fighting pests, you can find me on the golf course or out on a soccer field where I have been fortunate enough to coach soccer to kids of all ages for the past 20 years.